by Puffs » Mon Sep 02, 2019 3:52 am
Sorry to hear that Dave.
And I regret to have not advised you earlier to get a 2nd opinion on the sound, maybe from the rebore bloke, or a motorcycle mechanic in your area.
What you're describing on the big end is axial clearance. That is quite normal, and for the ETZ models the service limit is 1mm. And that's quite a bit. It's radial clearance, so up-down (with the crankshaft in TDC) which is normally the problem, it has a service limit (ETZ) of 0.05mm. Radial clearance is far more difficult to feel properly, unless the big end is really gone.
If you pull the conrod upwards with one hand, while bumping it downwards on the small end, with the muzzle of your other hand, do you hear a loud metallic clacking? That would indicate big end failure. It's a crude test, but the idea is to first pull all radial clearance to one side, and then suddenly push it to the other side. Do not try to test the sideways motion, that is rarely the problem.
On the small end, I do not really see a problem in the bearing cages you show. The one on the left is the original, and I see some signs of touching the inside of the small end, on the edges of the cage, but that probably shouldn't be an issue. With the piston pin in it, can you feel any radial play? I have had a small end failure on my 251 (some 18 years ago, no pictures), and it was quite obvious. Actually a lot more play than I expected from the sound, it did not sound all that bad.
Another problem could be the main bearings, of which there is one at each side of the crankshaft. You can rotate the crankshaft by rhythmically pushing/pulling the conrod up & down, staying in sync so that the crankshaft rotates. Do the bearings make any sort of crunchy or otherwise worrying sound? When the engine was running, main bearing failure is often indicated by a low end grumbling that can often be felt in the footrests. And in catastrophic failure they can seize, in a very loud manner, as I had in another bike.
How much play does the piston have in the barrel? Is it possible you're just hearing piston slap?
If you need another crankshaft, or just a conrod set, you can consider to take the engine out yourself, but have it taken apart & rebuilt by a mechanic. A conrod set is obviously a lot cheaper than a complete crankshaft, but pressing will also cost money. Regardless, if it comes apart you'll need new main bearings & seals.
The only mechanics I can advise you for the MZ is H&S Motors in Aberdeen, but I suspect they have retired by now. If you tell us where you are, maybe someone else can advise.
Last edited by
Puffs on Mon Jan 06, 2025 7:56 am, edited 2 times in total.